On February 3, 2009, the Arizona State Parks Board requested that the public have easy access to public comments about the budget. This page catalogs select communications received February 1 - 11, 2009.
Read Press Release about February 3 Board Meeting 
Watch Videos of Public Testimony from Feb. 3, 2009 meeting
Read Transcription of Public Testimony from Feb. 3, 2009 meeting
Submit Your Own Comments
Comments submitted through our online contact form may be posted on this page. All comments will be shared with the Arizona State Parks Board for budget discussions. Comments submitted become a matter of public record pursuant to A. R. S. §§ 39-121, et seq.
Just learned about the cancellation of the Civil War re-enactment. While I sympathize with the budget crunch, I am wondering about the negative effect cutting a few(relative term) dollars salary costs will have. Since over 200 re-enactors, and thousands of visitors will not be joining you, myself and wife included, how will this lack of tourism $ adversely affect your local economy. Was planning to visit Arizona for this event from Utah, spending a week in your state with 1 day at this event as the highlight. Obviously, We will not be coming now. If it were to get re-instated, or if you do it next year, please let me know. —Paul Smith
On behalf of Red Rock State Park Volunteers, ninety-four Sedona and Verde Valley residents, I am writing to inform you that we are deeply chagrined that our Governor, State Legislators, and Arizona State Parks Board would take action that might harm Red Rock State Park, a jewel in the crown of the Arizona State Parks System.
Though budgetary action must be taken, it should not be done at the loss of all that is freely generated beyond the budgetary allocations. Volunteers of Red Rock State Park annually donate, with our work and our labor, hours equal to seven full-time employees. Compared to other State Parks, whose volunteers donate 20% of total workforce hours, Red Rock State Park Volunteers donate 50%.
The Sedona community, as well as the approximately 80,000 visitors who come to our Park annually from throughout the United States and the world, derive satisfaction and fulfillment from its existence. So too do the hundreds of school children we serve through our State-approved educational programs. This land, with its surrounding scenery, is some of the most beautiful there is.
In short, Red Rock State Park is an invaluable asset that must be protected.
—Brenda M. Robinson
Volunteer Coordinator and Benefactors of Red Rock State Park Board Member
Please do not close Catalina State Park. I live in Oro Valley and when we have out of town visitors and relatives we take them to Catalina State Park. It is so beautiful and so accessible. —Rachel Rulmyr
The following was sent to the Arizona Republic yesterday. The controversy over the fourteen percent raise given to State Parks Director, Ken Travous needs a perspective that hasn't been discussed. First and foremost, the timing is, indeed, bad. To many readers, that is all that counts. However, I am former member of the Arizona State Parks Board. Like Chairman, Reese Woodling, I was on the Board when Ken Travous was promoted from Assistant Director to Executive Director. I served on the board for six years. Ken Travous was willing to take the promotion without a raise. The board did not feel that it was appropriate. Mr. Travous has turned down raises on several occasions to insure that his employees received a larger raise than was available. I have great respect for Travous and every employee of that agency who have worked to develop the system that is used by so many. Over the last several years, the legislature has refused to provide adequate funding even raiding the Heritage Fund, which was passed by the voters for other purposes. Travous and his staff worked hard to make the lack of funding work. As I said earlier, the timing is bad for such raises. However, Ken Travous is a very dedicated, hard working professional and he does not deserve some of the venom directed his way. —Ronald Pies
Oracle State Park is a treasure to all who love to hike, view wildlife, camp, enjoy the beauty of our state and horseback ride. Please do not close this wonderful park! It's an Arizona treasure! Thank you for your consideration – Jeanne Holm
I have a background in non-profit and marketing. I would be happy through Friends of Oracle State Park to make our public/private partnership stronger; so that the park can generate more revenue without changing its intended mission to be a wildlife refuge.
I am concerned about the manner in which the state parks have decided to deal with the budget cutbacks. Selecting several state parks to close based on attendance alone seems very arbitrary. Oracle State Park serves a unique function among the jewels of state parks within our state. It alone offers Environmental Education Programs for school age children. It also has the historic Kannally Ranch House which can generate revenues that help support the Park. It also has one of the strongest volunteer organization in the state supporting it. Another way must be found to keep all parks open, but especially Oracle State Park. I am currently training to be a volunteer there. Please do not deprive me of this way to give back to the state!! —Kathi Sanders
My husband and I have volunteered for 6 years at Sonoita Creek State Natural Area. We are impressed and pleased with the extensive use of volunteers in the education program there. However, cutting funding to State Parks would reduce the quality of park visitors because infrastructure of the parks must be maintained and a staff must be available to guide the programming and do much of the day to day work. Patagonia Lake State Park and SCSNA serve an area that utilizes the facilities and needs to see that the present level of services is maintained. There are no frills at these two facilities. There must be funding to at least sustain our level of services without cuts. —Sally Lockwood
As a teacher that takes three 5th grade classes to the park (Oracle State Park) annually for educational field trips I urge the ASP board members to reconsider closing the park for the sake of the 100's of students that visit the park for the same reason. —Casey Egan
I am concerned about park closings. It would be a crime to lose parks that were acquired/added to the park system at great cost - in their day. I'm sure those that worked so hard to secure the parks that are now in danger of closing never thought that leadership with such short-sighted vision would consider throwing away their hard fought efforts. We need every park. We won't get them back. We need to consider adding more in the future when the budget allows. Cut the funding for some programs, cut the printing budget, look for special interest industry sponsors (like the mining industry for the park in Jerome) but don't close the parks. We are just seeing the roots of volunteerism take hold and President Obama has asked us to all lend a hand and volunteer. Please do not take away our opportunity to show what we can do for AZ state parks. We can get through these hard times if we work together to make it happen. —Nancy Bowman
Please don't close this park (Lyman). It is enjoyable for us locals and the visitors. —Rhonda Koellen
This park is extremely important to my family and to this community. Oracle State Park is unique in offering educational opportunities to 2000 plus students a year as well as all of us who live here and visit the park. The seminars are outstanding. Our community is one of the poorest since the mines closed. The few businesses in town benefit greatly from all the park visitors. Please do not close this jewel in the desert. Let's find a way to keep it open for all to use. As a volunteer at Oracle State park and a member of the Friends of Oracle State Park marketing committee, I am looking for ways to make our park of value to the greatest number of people. Any information could be of great use. —Mary Ann Pogany
This message is for Arizona State Board Chairman, Reese Woodling, in regards to the possible closure of the eight National Parks here in Arizona. Before I begin, I would like to point out that I do now know of the minute details entailed within the budget cuts, nor am I aware of exactly how much and in what ways the funding of these parks is used, but I do know some of the immediate consequences that will follow the closure of such important parks. I am only a Freshman here at the U of A, but I believe that this is something I could not respond to, even if its through the azstateparks mailer.
These State Parks were set up for a reason and that reason is the preservation of historical landmarks as well as the biodiversity within said parks. I know that chairman Woodling is aware of the complexity and dire importance of preserving things such as the archaeological record in little places like the Homol'ovi Ruins State Park. I know the ultimate say in whether or not certain budgets will be cut does not like with the AZ State Parks, but rather the Arizona legislature so, it is important that messages such as mine will be relayed to higher offices, so that the voices of the public can be heard.
I want the State Legislature to reconsider the appropriations of funds in such a manner that is unwasteful and actually beneficial, both logically and economically. Think about it, if eight State Parks are closed, where does that leave my generation, let alone generations to follow? With growing populations and a worsening environment, what will the public have left? Mountains? Or will those eventually be inhabited? It is imperative to keep these parks open, not only so tourist and locals can come "look" at flowers and cacti, but rather, so people can understand the world just a little bit better and can enjoy what peoples before us have also enjoyed and to make use of this enjoyment by utilizing it by converting it into knowledge. Do not deprive the public from this integral knowledge by cutting eight State Parks, but rather turn them into something that the public can benefit from and that the State can utilize as a means of a return in profit.
It is up for debate what these programs and processes of achieving these goals might be, but it is vital that they be discussed before the closure of these parks as well as loss of jobs by park employees. Take into consideration that if the Park is closed, they will just shut the doors, turn off the lights, and leave. There will be no protection in place for the ruins or for the Park's infrastructure. The collections will be sent to Phoenix. This presents a serious situation to the integrity of the archaeological record that the Park was created to preserve. In the last two years they have successfully partnered with the Hopi Tribe in developing and expanding interpretation in the Park. Visitation and interest have been on the rise. There are better alternative routes to achieve common goals so it is our responsibility to make sure they are achieved properly and effectively.
Lastly, I want to point out that I know there are contradictions with what I have written, for there is no way of me knowing all the entities involved, but think about it, I'd be more that willing to discuss and help out in the preservation of these State Parks!
Sincerely —Jason Seaman
I am concern with the closing. Why don't you increase the fee from $6 to 10$ and off annual passes. —Dean Salman
I am proud to say I am a volunteer and a "Friends" member at Oracle State Park. The park has a unique history with the Historical Kannally Ranch House and ranching history. We also enjoy the 4000 acres of oakgrass land and desert. I believe the hiking trails (including the historic AZ trail) are unique as all ages can enjoy. Closing the OSP would effect many people, hikers, history buffs, bikers, equestrians, bird watchers, artist, educational for young and old. Approximately 1,500 school children a year enjoy and learn from the Environmental Education Program. Please keep this open space and conservation of OSP history and animal habitat OPEN. The effects of closing would hurt the park and it's Historic value and the entire Community. —Cindy Krupicka
I have recently read the article on the closing of Riordan Mansion State Park. Two things really bother me about this.
One: the seriously flawed cost analysis in the closing of this state historic landmark. The loss of $ 5 per head of everyone who comes to visit. A state park is someone who preserves a part of the past that would otherwise be lost. I believe the accountant should be cut, to better preserve the mansion. A year by year analysis, has cycles, and when one year is good, and 3 or 4 years are better, well, you just shouldn't expect that source of income in perpetuity. Why? because life (and money) naturally ebbs and flows. Just because you no longer have good years do you relinquish (or cut off your right arm) a unique historical landmark.
Two: The many thousands of people who visit are exposed to the unique history of this mansion. Many types of programs are offered by the staff and supporting volunteers on the culture of Flagstaff, and Northern Arizona, in an 1880 to 1890 to a progression to the present day. This historical sequencing of events is a highlight that will be lost, because a flawed and delusional accountant says that everyone who pays to see history as it once was, is costing the state $ 5 a head. Money and historical uniqueness and integrity will be lost forever, if this mansion is closed. —Alex DiNatale, cartographer, 35 year northern Arizona resident
This is for all State Parks and of course the smaller ones like Fort Verde State Park located in Camp Verde. This town has so little, now you are thinking of closing the one thing that brings people from miles away! I cannot tell you how impressed my family was when they came from Germany as they read the history of our Fort Verde Park. You will be taking away even more history from our children. May I volunteer my time and teach some people how to handle money? —Sandi Ashton
I am a Flagstaff resident wand would very much like to see a solution that leaves Riordan Mansion SHP open. Not only is it of significant local historical value but the ongoing lecture series is of immense interest to many residents. —Donovan Wood
The decision to even consider closing state parks is very sad. The rich history of this wonderful state would forever be lost. And the effect on the economies of rural communities could be devastating. I've seen the results of decisions like this in the past. The site becomes a marker, the marker then deteriorates and the history is lost to future generations. Look to changes in administration and upper management, consolidate and learn to manage effectively. Get rid of the bureaucracy and focus on the front line. Include those individuals in the decision process. Their ideas and solutions may surprise you. —James Hasapis
The closure of Riordan Mansion State Historic Park would be a great loss to the school children in Flagstaff. The staff at Riordan Mansion has developed a wonderful, informative presentation for students to learn about Flagstaff and Arizona history. The park is not just a piece of visual beauty; it is a component of education that is valuable to us all. —Gwen Groth, Flagstaff
The news that Homovoli Ruins Park may be closed is devastating. Historians, researchers and archaeologists have considered it a valuable resource for many years. As well, being here in this museum in nearby Winslow for over three years, I am aware of the number of visitors to the area that also have it on their "to do" list.
In addition to that, it is of significance to the Hopi, whose early habitation of this area cannot be separated from this site. Closed, it will likely be a target for plunder and vandalization, as it was in years past. It would be a travesty for a door to close on this valuable resource, and for it to be put at risk in any way. Please do not allow this to materialize. Sincerely —Lila Atkins, Director, Old Trails Museum
I have been a volunteer/docent at the Riordan Mansion State Historic Park since Aug. of 2006. The "mansion" was an unbelievable gift from a wonderful family which has done and is still doing much to support their community and the citizens of Arizona. To lose the park would not only be a great loss of history and an unbelievable blow to visitors but also a slap in the face to people who have done so much for the citizens of this state. The best way to reduce the parks deficit would be to increase the number of visitors. We're all working hard to do that; help us. —Marilyn Ruggles
I do not know if this correspondence will be viewed by the Arizona Parks Board, but I am hoping that it is. I understand that you, the Park Board, are in process of tackling your part of the state budget crisis by cutting back services and closing state parks. In addition, I heard that Lyman Lake State Park, St. Johns, AZ is one of the parks that is on the chopping block. Please, please consider what you're doing with an open mind and the needs of Arizona citizens. I am 69 years young, so yes I do understand fully a financial crisis, because I have lived through my fare share of them. What concerns me most is the citizens of this great state. As we all know, people are loosing their jobs or hours/pay is being cut as businesses and government attempt to get through the crisis. People do not have the money to spend on recreation, but NEED recreation to get through the stress that is truly caused by the times. So what do we do? Many citizen head to the state and county parks for an inexpensive weekends of fun. It may not fix the problem and when we return to our homes after the weekend, the problem remains, but at the very least, they get away from reality for a few days / hours. My question is "why"! Why do we always chop programs that really do not cost much but are used by the average family who need the escape? As for Lyman Lake State Park - This is the jewel of the Arizona State Park system. It is in a simply beautiful setting and has facility for many types of recreational pleasures such as fishing, boating, etc. It is a fairly easy drive from the three major metropolitan areas Phoenix, Tucson, and Flagstaff and because it is a state park the cost is reasonable. My wife and I have been to most of the state parks in Arizona and like Lyman Lake over the rest. I hope and pray, that the Park Board will find other ways to cut without closing parks. WE NEED OUR STATE PARKS!!! Thank you for your time and consideration, Sincerely —Frank B. and Dana R. Fischer, Phoenix
As Historian I value the traditions and lessons passed down to us from older generations. When I learned that the Riordan Mansion was slated for possible closure to repair state budget issues I had to speak out. I also have a financial and emotional vested interest in the Park because it is to be the site of my wedding in June of this year. The mission of the state parks is to preserve our history and natural wonders for future generations, please do not allow state bureaucrats to steal that away from us. —Joshua McCauley, Midshipman, United States Naval Academy
In spite of fiscal difficulties facing the state, closure of Oracle State Park will ultimately be more costly than keeping it opens. These costs go beyond monetary considerations.
Youth environmental education programs are covered by volunteers and provide a much needed experience to the next generation. Also, the historic value of the Park, once a working ranch including the Kannaly adobe house, is important to our state's cultural identity. Finally, rural Arizona, always much harder hit by economic hardships, is provided with an affordable family recreation by the park's presence.
Please keep Oracle State Park open. —Sherri Ziegler & Dick Kirkpatrick
Concerns over closing this Park as it has the Arizona Trail running through it. Do you propose to close both? Closing puts the Park's facilities open to vandalism etc. Before the State took over, unknown persons were growing marijuana at the park! —Harry McWilliams
The state park in Oracle has a strong volunteer base that works at the park and provides funds for park improvements. There is also a large number of hikers that use the park because of the Arizona Trail. The other trails in the park are popular at different times of the year because of the elevation (4500') and because of the proximity to Tucson. Oracle is a small community and the park is an important resource. Save our park!! —Larry and Nyla Butler
I have been a historical interpretive volunteer for Arizona State Parks for over 16 years. I recently had the extreme pleasure and privilege of holding a Victorian Clothing Workshop for 22 participants at Deadhorse State Park. Along with my friend and colleague, Terri Leverton, who is a State Park Assistant manager, we spent the day discussing ladies clothing of the Territorial Arizona era. All were enthusiastic and were eager to use their new information to design a "Living History Persona" and volunteer at one of the Historical Parks. When these ladies have E mailed me to get a schedule of upcoming events, I sadly had to tell them that my beloved Az Parks were closing, and that ALL historical re enactments were going to be cancelled until further notice because of budget cuts. I have since found out that some of the parks are going to be allowed to continue with certain programs. It truly saddens me to think that our state cares so little about our history and culture that it has allowed things to come to this. Do you realize how many school groups take advantage of your education programs? Do you realize how many senior citizens we (living historians) encounter every season that comment positively on how our state is preserving their memories of times gone by? Do you care that by closing the historical Parks, you will be loosing a part of Arizona's wonderful past that will never be able to be brought back again? Do you care? After reading the article explaining the current Park Director’s enormous raise and his upcoming retirement, I think you most likely do not.
I have whole-heartedly supported the State Parks, as I said earlier, for over 16 years. My husband and my son have also been faithful volunteers. We have spent lots of time developing historically correct "camps" settings, participated in many programs at several historical sites, spent lots and lots of time and money for you-to make your agency look good. We have only asked that you allow us to do what we love-share of passion for our State's past with others! That is what I am asking, no, begging now. Please, please, please reconsider closing the historical parks. Are there not some alternative schedules or creative managing that could be done? It would be a crime if our State's history was allowed to die-especially so close to it's 100th birthday!!! Please, allow us to help you by helping us to do what we love-allow us to continue to celebrate our past and share it with the future. Please don't "make ghosts" of the re enactors and living historians. Thank you for your time. If you would like to further discuss what I can do for you, please contact me at the E mail address listed! —Kelley Christopher-Gaston, State Parks Historical Interpretive Volunteer
Riordan Mansion is the most impressive example we have of Flagstaff's past. It's available both rain & shine to both locals and tourists and it would be a shame to see it close. Hopefully, something can be worked out to keep this unique jewel of Flagstaff available to all. —Louise and Crandall Jones
I'm Shifra Leah Boehlje, a resident of Phoenix and volunteer at Fort Verde State Historic Park. I am concerned about the possible closing and subsequent destruction of this beautiful historic landmark.
We must all be vigilant in saving our few remaining historic buildings as a legacy for our future generations. If we don't preserve these buildings and artifiacts we will be destroying the only remaining monuments devoted to the memory of those soldiers who gave their lives for this GREAT STATE. You have been empowered as stewards of this history and must protect and maintain these buildings and artifacts as such.
I am so dedicated to this cause that I will do all within my power to save this fort and our history. —Shifra Leah Boehlje
I am sad to read in today's paper that Riordan St Pk was chosen for possible closing. The staff and volunteers do a super job of community outreach with Tuesday BB lectures and monthly Saturday night presentations. I have been particularly impressed by Kathy Faretta who goes beyond her job responsibilities to let the community know about Riordan and lines up speakers from a wide range of topics. The gap in cost/ per visitor between Riordan and others seems significant enough to warrant reconsideration of closing Riordan. Also, what would happen to the valuable collection house there? —Beverly Loomis
I read at AZ Central that Ken Travous is recommending closing the Yuma Quartermaster Depot. How can we close a park that has such strong ties to the development of our great state? The other ones recommended for immediate closure, if one must close any, I can live with. But the Quartermaster Depot?
And what becomes of the parks that are closed? Are they just going to be left to go to ruin? What a travesty!
I wish the state of AZ would give ME the budget. I bet I can find cuts that have nothing to do with slamming the doors shut on our rich and wonderful history! —Brenda Jackson
I am a professional archaeologist from the Arizona State Museum who has worked at Homol'ovi Ruins State Park since before its founding in 1986. It was created in part to protect the fragile and vulnerable ruins within its boundaries and has done an admirable job doing so. It has formed a partnership with the Hopi Tribe to expand interpretation to these ancient Hopi communities. By closing the Park you make it completely vulnerable to the vandalism to to the petroglyphs and ruins which would be devastating to the history of this state and the Hopi people. These ruins are unique and cannot be replaced. I urge you to take into consideration your obligation to protect these ancient communities in perpetuity, which was the expectation when Homol'ovi Ruins State Park was created. —Charles Adams
I am concerned about a rumor I'm hearing about closure of AZ State Parks. Currently I'm at Catalina State Park and have been very impressed with the cleanliness, order, and professionalism here. The area I'm in is full nearly every night and often there are people waiting for sites. The group campground is also highly used. So far I've met people from Ohio, New York, British Columbia, and and Colorado, as well as Arizona. All of the nonlocals are bringing money into the Tucson area with their business.
Over the years, in Colorado, many of my friends have talked about visits to AZ and staying in your state parks. The park system is special, apparently well-run, and encourages people to visit.
Some type of rotating closures would make sense to me, with parks being closed (with protection) during the slowest times. Complete closure of popular, highly used parks makes no sense. Those parks provide havens for residents as well as pulling in visitors.
Thank you for this opportunity to share my views. —Barbara A. Tiems
Prior commitments prevent me from attending the February 3rd State Parks Board Meeting. In the alternative, I respectfully request that this letter be read and included in the minutes of the meeting.
I was surprised and disgusted with the manner (last minute amendment) in which the State Legislature included the stripping of $500,000.00 of Law Enforcement and Boating Safety Fund monies for the purpose of making up the State’s current budget shortfall. The loss of these monies represents a reduction of anywhere from 25% to 50% of funds to be allocated to 8 Arizona Counties for the purposes of enforcing Boating Law, presenting Boating Safety Classes, accident investigation and prevention, and other public awareness of Boating and Water Safety.
This loss severely reduces the County’s ability to patrol the State’s waterways and reduce and prevent Boating Accidents, injuries and deaths. This is a severe Public Safety issue, and puts Arizona boaters, residents and visitors alike, at a higher risk of accident, injury and death.
I urge the Board to do everything within their power to try and reinstate these monies back into the Law Enforcement and Boating Safety Fund, protect the fund from any further Legislative appropriation, and ensure that any future funds deposited into the Law Enforcement and Boating Safety Fund are allocated to the Arizona County Sheriff’s for the purpose stated in ARS § 5-583.
Respectfully Submitted,
—Lt. Alan Nelson
Boating Safety Division Supervisor
La Paz County Sheriff’s Office
As a councilwoman for the Town of Camp Verde, actions proposed by the State Parks Board to balance their budget could be of great impact and concern to Camp Verde.
Fort Verde, is located in the center of our Town and is a focus point of our efforts to attract tourism to our historic downtown area. Closing of this State Park will be have far-reaching effects on our community already dealing with housing foreclosures, budget shortfalls and related problems which are occurring throughout the state.
Camp Verde has enjoyed a long and successful relationship with State Parks, accomplishing many projects such as our swimming pool and skateboard park, river access parks and upgrades to the Fort with Heritage funds.
Once again the State Legislature is looking at a short term solution for a long range problem. It is perfectly understandable that the Heritage Funds set aside by the voters in 1990 would appear to be a good source of quick money with the magnitude of the budget shortfall facing our state.
Legislature's desire to balance their budget on the backs of the Heritage and LTAF monies is not in the best interested of the State of Arizona.
Please do not close our State Park.
Sincere regards,
—Norma Garrison
Councilwoman
I read the news article in the Arizona Daily Star regarding State budget cuts and the possibility of closing State Parks. While I am certain the closure of any State Park is a very bad idea. I am particulary concerned about the possible closure of Catalina State Park, near Tucson.
I am a Tucson resident, use this park frequently and always buy a State Parks Pass. I feel the closure of this park would be a grave disservice to the communities of Tucson, Marana, Oro Valley, and Catalina. In this time of economic hardship, people are in desperate need of relatively inexpensive, yet meaningful, pursuits that are enjoyable for the whole family. I spent several hours at Catalina State Park on Sunday with several friends, and we noted the large numbers of families with children of all ages hiking and picnicking in this park. Elderly people were enjoying the trails, groups of friends were doing the same, people were taking their dogs for walks and romps in the water, and some folks who were unable to do much walking were happily sitting under the trees admiring the bounty of nature. My friends and I were birding … a very popular pass time in the park. I know large groups of all types use this wonderful park and have for years. This is too valuable a treasure to deny the people … especially in this time of national stress.
Please, encourage those in positions of power to not close our parks … especially Catalina State Park. Thank you —Darlene Smith
I am truly concerned about the decision to close Homol'ovi Ruins State Park. The State's commitment to its heritage and peoples are truly in jeopardy. Budgetary crises ebb and flow and are a regular part of life. The dismantling of a Park such as this is irreparable, losing the very connections that made the State of AZ what it is. Also, the thought of abandoning exposed archaeological ruins to vulnerabilities of looting and the elements, when you recognized its importance and signed on to protect such assets goes against every moral and ethical bone of the mission the Parks Board is supposed to uphold. There must be a way, through active public comment and bringing the key stakeholders around the table to find an acceptable solution to weather yet another budgetary issue. Don't think reactively but proactively. There are many people and cultures that care. Once you close there is no turning back. Being a graduate of U of A, I know that AZ is far more innovative than that. Work a little harder. Your efforts here will be felt by the future generations to come. AZ is a the crown where all its jewels sits. Don't pawn it off. —Cindy Randall
We are most distressed to learn of the potential closing of RIORDAN MANSION STATE HISTORIC PARK. The mansion, and its contents of artifacts and treasures from more than 100 years ago, is one of the last places in Arizona that presents the story of Flagstaff and Northern Arizona in their early, upstart years. The Mansion has been featured in state and national publications as one of the architectural gems of the early 20th century. Flagstaff students learn local and state history in the rooms at Riordan, and adults attend twice-monthly lectures on local history. RIORDAN MANSION and its staff make history come alive for thousands of visitors and locals every year. We hope the "can-do" spirit of Arizona's pioneers will help the Parks Board craft creative ways to keep RIORDAN MANSION and other worthy parks up and running. —Karen & Dave Washabau
Thanks for continuing to send me the latest information on our state parks. Our parks add much to our lives and I hope that they are able to survive in these difficult economic times. Keep up your great work and thanks again. —Phil Evanstock
While perhaps not put in a politically correct manner, it appears that once again the State Legislature is looking at a short term solution for a long range problem. It is perfectly understandable that the Heritage Funds set aside by the voters in 1990 would appear to be a good source of "quick money" with the magnitude of the budget shortfall facing our state for FY 2009 and FY 2010. And this of course is not only a state problem, but national and international as well. We are in a recession, the magnitude of which is unknown, as will be the duration.
However, the Board over the years has been successful in withstanding "raids" on these funds, and I can only hope they remain consistent in protecting these monies for the purposes they were intended. Most assuredly political pressures are being applied to your agency and board in the Legislature's desire to balance their budget; however many of the elected officials are new and perhaps do not realize the ripple effect cutting Heritage and LTAF monies will have on all communities throughout the state.
As a citizen I am most familiar with the use of Heritage funds in the community I live in, Camp Verde. I was privileged to serve on the Town's Parks and Recreation Commission for a number of years as well as the General Plan Committee that had widespread community involvement and participation defining Camp Verde's desires for our community. We are, as defined in 1972, and remain a small, western rural community. This was restated in our General Plan of 1998, and Growing Smarter Plan of 2004, appreciating our setting in the Verde Valley, protective of our assets which include Beasley Flat, the White Bridge Park, Fort Verde, Montezuma Castle, the White Hills, Copper Canyon, Chasm, Brown Springs with 18 miles of the Verde River bisecting our community and lands of the Coconino and Prescott Forests within our incorporated boundaries.
Over the years Heritage Funds have enabled completion of many projects that have improved our community and quality of life. In-kind donations and sweat equity of our residents has been an integral part of every project. Citizens even agree with a sales tax levied and set aside for Parks. Our current grant request, now to be placed on hold, is a culmination of 18 years of work to acquire permanent parkland. Funds were allocated by various town councils, as feasible, to enable goals set by the community. Contributions were made by citizens. Citizens defined the historic trail system and donate their time to work on trails and clean up realizing the lack of funding in the federal and state agencies. All of which tie into protecting and enhancing the beauty of our natural setting. We do not have high sales tax revenues as our community has remained more agricultural and pursued industry that does not conflict with the goals referenced above.
Please do what you can to advocate for our community, and others like us. Time is of the essence with your board meeting Tuesday, February 3rd but volumes of paperwork could be submitted to document the above if time allowed. Good luck with the tough decisions facing your agency, but the financial crisis will pass, our land, mountains and streams should continue to be preserved for future generations.
Sincere regards
—Suzy Burnside
I read in today's paper that the Parks are considering closing up to 8 Parks. Has anyone considered in searching retired senior volunteers to keep them open. Perhaps you could find a number of them to change off the duties every two or three months in exchange for a hook-up for their RV. —Jon Smith
Very interested in keeping Catalina State Park open. We go there at least twice a week to hike and enjoy the beauty. It is a real Tucson treasure. We would be willing to pay double the yearly fee. Another suggestion is to collect fees from bicyclists. I know it states that they pay $2.00 but we have never seen one pay yet. Up the fees for all to save the park. Thanks for listening. —Cynthia Flynn
Our local Tucson newspaper reported that Catalina is one of the parks that may have to be closed due to budget cuts. This would be a shame as this park is used by so many people in an area that has grown rapidly over the last few years. My husband and I visit the park at least once a week. The parking lot is always full of cars. Also, the opening of Oro Valley Marketplace across the street has made many more people aware of the park. Please do not close this park! Thanks. —Lauri Israel
I am one of over 90 Sedona and Verde Valley residents who volunteers at Red Rock State Park. Our Park is an environmental education Park that provides school programs to thousands of students every year, not only from the Verde Valley, but from areas throughout Arizona and neighboring states. The Park is a haven for wildlife and birds and a treasure of geological and archeological history for the area. The House of Apache Fires sits on the Park and is a historical landmark. 80,000 visitors annually enjoy and appreciate all the Park has to offer.
Volunteers of Red Rock State Park annually donate hours equal to seven full-time employees. In addition to the small, dedicated staff, the volunteers are able to assume responsibility for a variety of tasks, including teaching, leading hikes, assisting with the Entry Station and Gift Shop, and providing maintenance for the trails and Park structures.
Red Rock State Park, situated on lower Oak Creek, is a magnificent example of the delights of Red Rock Country! It is a refuge for anyone who wants to enjoy the beauty of nature and the peace and quiet of a wildlife preserve. This Park is an invaluable asset to the Verde Valley as well as the State Park System and must be protected.
We understand the need to reduce costs. However, we hope that in reducing costs, we do not fail to recognize what Red Rock State Park has been providing for our public with limited cost to the State because of its strong volunteer program. In addition, the eight Rangers, three of whom may lose their jobs, are committed to the preservation of the Park and its mission.
Thank you for your consideration. —Karen Hatler
It was with alarm that I learned on Sat. that there will likely be Arizona State Parks closures announced after a meeting on Tuesday.
I live in Sedona and lead nature walks as a volunteer at Red Rock State Park. Red Rock State Park has attracted nearly 100 volunteers who annually contribute hours equal to seven full-time employees. Our Park visitors come from all over the United States and from countries all over the world. They are usually awed by the beauty of Sedona and extremely appreciative of their educational experiences at the Park.
In addition, the hundreds of school children who participate in the Red Rock State Park's outdoor education programs thoroughly benefit from spending time outdoors learning about their Arizona environment.
Sedona is generally considered to be one of the special places in the world and it would indeed be a shame to close this special Park that leaves such a positive impression of Arizona in our many American and international visitors.
Please do not consider closing this valuable asset to Arizona—Red Rock State Park.
Thank you.
—Patricia L. List
Volunteer at Red Rock State Park
Former Board Member of the Benefactors of Red Rock State Park
I purchased a one year pass in January 2009. I have only used it once. If you close the equestrian trails at Catalina State Park I will not be able to travel to the other parks. Will my money be refunded. The only reason I purchased the year pass was the because the park was within a few miles of where my horse is boarded. —Lisa Tilton
I want to tell you how distressed I am that Arizona might take action that would harm Red Rock State Park, a special location in the Arizona State Parks System. Red Rock State Park is located in a geologically unique area of north central Arizona near Sedona. It encompasses between one and two river miles of Arizona s perennial Oak Creek, offering a wealth of both riparian and upland plant and animal species. The park is also included in the Lower Oak Creek Important Bird Area.
As documented on the University of Arizona's website, riparian areas form some of the most productive habitats in North America and create ribbons of life in the arid climate of the American Southwest. In the arid western United States, riparian areas are estimated at less than 2% of the total land area. In Arizona, riparian areas may form only 0.4% of the total land area. Is it possible that such an important area could become unavailable to Arizona s residents and visitors ?
The Sedona community, as well as the approximately 80,000 visitors who come to our Park annually from throughout the United States and the world, derive satisfaction and fulfillment from its existence. So too do the hundreds of school children we serve through our State-approved educational programs. This land, with its surrounding scenery, is some of the most beautiful in the world.
I believe Red Rock State Park is an invaluable asset that must be protected and preserved for today and for future generations.
—Ann Magetteri
Volunteer, Red Rock State Park
I have just become aware of the State of Arizona's plans to close several State Parks. I am writing this note as a plea to reconsider Catalina State Park as a potential victim of our current economic conditions. As you are probably aware, Catalina State Park is a vital recreational and educational asset of metropolitan Tucson and Pima County. Over the last 20 years significant growth has taken place north of Tuscon leaving CSP virtually an urban oasis. This park is used year round, especially when Tucson hosts world reknowned cultural events. In the summer the park provides respite from the southern Arizona heat. It is used by tens of thousands of hikers, horseback riders, school groups, archeologists, conservation groups, the University of Arizona extension, etc. The loss of the use of this park would be devastating to Tucson, Pima County, and all of Southern Arizona. Sincerely —Lee Cunningham
I can not make the meeting this morning and would like to know what state parks you are planning on closing? Please explore other options before choosing this. —Vanessa Farias
Please don't close Fort Verde State Park. Our children and other visitors receive very little accurate information on this period of Arizona history from other sources and the loss of these historic structures and artifacts would be irreplaceable. Thanks. —Lon Wolff
KEEP LYMAN LAKE STATE PARK OPEN! I visit Lyman Park 5-6 time each year, and it is my favorite park, just 105 miles from Gallup. PLEASE KEEP LYMAN LAKE OPEN! We campers will be happy to PAY HIGHER FEES to keep Lyman open. Just raise the fee level to balance the budget. Thank you —Stephen Buggie, UNM-Gallup, Gallup NM. NOTE, Gallup is a border town, on the AZ state line. Although we are in New Mexico, we feel we are part of Arizona also. Half the students at our UNM branch campus are Arizona residents.
I was shocked this morning when I read the news that our beloved, pristine park in Oracle will be closed. I understand that our state budget is and has been under scrutiny for quite sometime. Why is it that which we hold dear is always the first on the chopping block? The park is where we hike, take classes, enjoy our annual Calabazas Festival. Please do whatever it takes to restore Oracle State Park for use by its tri-community residents. Thank you for your attention. —Barbara Walss
I'm writing to express my deep concern that Ken Travous has suggested closing several of Arizona's Historical Parks and I don't know that he has tried to cut his budget for personnel on his immediate staff or to think "out of the box" to reduce hours and some staff so that the parks can stay open on a scaled down version. How ironic that we are going to be celebrating our Centennial in 2012 and hundreds of people and millions of dollars are being spent on the Legacy Projects to celebrate the 100 year old birthday of Arizona and in the meantime historical state parks are being considered for closure. Please look into Mr. Travous' caviler suggestions to close these parks when there are many other alternatives available. Also, I don't know if you are aware that Fort Verde in Camp Verde is in a similar legal situation as the Riordan Mansion State Historic Park. In 1970 the Camp Verde Historical Society gave Arizona State Parks several of the buildings, parcels of land, and hundreds of inventory items to be used by Fort Verde. The agreement has the property and the entire inventory reverting to the Camp Verde Historical Society, which would be a huge burden on the society, but one that will be pursued. Again, please put every effort into preserving our state parks. Thank you.
I will also be sending the same comments to my Legislatures; hope we can save some of our parks from being closed. —Nancy Floyd
We are extremely disappointed that the board is considering closing the Riordan Mansion State Park. We have only lived in AZ/Flagstaff for 2 years but one of our main sources of pride and entertainment is the Riordan. The educational events held at the mansion are very professionally done as well as entertaining. Plus when we attend tours/events at the mansion we always meet numerous people from out of state that are always so complimentary of the Park and the effectiveness of the volunteers. Please do not close this facility. It has taken years to get it to where it is today and closing it at this time would set it back years. Thanks for your consideration! —Ken and Charlene Pinkston
Many years ago I was a volunteer at Riordan State Park and was hired on as a park ranger. I implore you to avoid at all costs the closing of our parks, any of them. Please examine any and all ideas that can be thought of. How about corporate sponsors of rooms at historic parks and picnic areas or camping areas at other parks, how about closing low use parks from Thanksgiving to Easter. Raise admission fees somewhat. I read that McFarland charges $3.00, that's what Riordan charged 15 years ago, why not $5.00? Riordan now charges $6.00, would people pay $7.50? How about $10.00 per car (or even $20) instead of $5.00 per car at recreational parks? Sell advertising space in the park brochures. I am sure that all these ideas have already been thought of and many more. Please consider ALL of them before taking a drastic step and closing the states treasures, many of them would be gone forever. The decisions made today will affect our children's children and their children, you are not deciding just how to handle a budget crunch today, you are deciding what part of our history will be left to future generations 20,50, even 100 years from now. —Colin Judd
Please do not close any of the parks, please explore all options available prior to cuts. These parks are a wealth of information for all visitors about our state, whether they live here or not. I grew up by the San Rafael State Park (I know it is not open yet) I have been to the Sharp Ranch as we called it many times and I would love to see it be open to people so they can see what a gorgeous area and what a great acquisition the San Rafael area is to the state parks. Also Riordan Mansion is fantastic, please do all possible to keep this one open. Patagonia Lake is where so many of my childhood memories are at. Tombstone courthouse was a once a year trip for our family. The Tubac Presidio is another one that I have enjoyed so many times, please keep these parks open. I understand how tough times are, but could you sell advertisements for local businesses somewhere in the parks? I understand that it may take away from the natural look or periodic look of the parks, but tough times call for creative thinking, not closures. I will use the PBR (Professional Bull Riders) as an example, when these cowboys started out they didn't have sponsors, they relied on the paying customer, but just like Nascar, these cowboys are all plastered in ads. Did it take away from their performance? No, it enhanced the event and those ads now help pay those cowboys' winnings. Please consider other options prior to closing. I do hope that you can find solutions for the budget shortfalls we are experiencing. Thank you for your job. —Susana Judd
I love Riordan Mansion because it tells the story of Flagstaff and has lots of historic artifacts which help kids like me understand history. All the State Parks are important because each one is special in it's own way. I have 19 Junior Ranger pins and I would like the chance to get them all. Please don't close any parks. —Amelia Lober, age 10
The Riordan Mansion has been designated as a historic site by the State of Arizona. How can it be closed? What would happen to it? It's not land. It needs care and must be preserved for the public to see as a cultural and historic treasure. —Suzanne Warren
As a concession of Arizona State Parks for over 25 years, Sandpoint's staff and guests are understandably upset at the prospect of any State Park being closed but particularly Cattail Cove State Park who has been both neighbor and friend for many many years. The residents of Arizona don't deserve to have one of the last venues of relaxation, education and lifelong memories taken away at a time when we need them the most. The State Parks still offers an easy and cost effective way for "everyone" to enjoy what our State has to offer in a time when a little "enjoyment" is strongly needed. There has to be another way that would allow our State Parks to remain intact and enjoyed. Closing our State Parks is not the solution. Sincerely, —Lisa Lepree, General Manager Sandpoint Marina & RV Park, Lake Havasu City, AZ
I am retired and do a lot of RV camping. I love our state and try to make use of its many resources. I've seen several articles on the closing of many of our parks and/or requiring the reduction of services/access days all do the fiscal constraints facing Arizona. One alternative I've not seen is the use of "camping" volunteers, aside from your established volunteer program. We are currently at the height of the "Snow Bird" season. Most are retired, are "full time" RV campers and are staying in our State Parks. Why not approach these RVers and ask that they volunteer to act as hosts (duties to be defined). They could be compensated for their help by offering a "free" site. Just a thought. —Eugene T. Vargas
Homol'ovi Ruins State Park was created to protect and preserve ancient Hopi villages excavated over the course of 20 years. If left untended, the park and its archaeological sites will be vulnerable to destruction. Be forward thinking; preserve Arizona's heritage. Do not close Homol'ovi State Park. —Margot Ellis
I received an e-mail from the Arizona State Parks Board of the budget to be discussed. Don't you tax your people? I live in Daytona Florida and since 2000, there has been an echo tourism program from tax payers money. Ecological Cultural historical and outdoor recreation. The area is bountiful with culture, nature and other great things for the tourists to enjoy. Look on the web at ECHO Tourism, Volusia county for an example of what could be good for Arizona. Very truly, —Marcia Kreeger
Thank you all for not closing our beautiful Arizona Park Lands! I know with creativity and hard work you can make it work! I frequent Lost Dutchman Park 5 Days a Week 12 Months a year! What you people do with the little you have is amazing! Thank you all so much for allowing me and the tourists (who drive me crazy in the winter) the opportunity to see our AMAZING BEAUTIFUL STATE!!!! Thanks again!! Your hard work is APPRECIATED AND DOES NOT!!!! Go Unnoticed!!! —John Hiscott
We are residents of Virginia and have friends who live in Flagstaff. We are distressed to hear that the Riordan Mansion is being considered for closure. We have visited Riordan and thoroughly enjoyed the tour, its unique history and its wonderful architecture. It was especially nice to meet its knowledgeable staff and volunteers who provided many interesting stories and details about the park. We hope to visit Riordan again and encourage the board to keep this park available for enjoyment by everyone. Arizona should be commended for maintaining this unique place in history, open for public education and appreciation. —Dan & Barbara Robertson
Top of Page 
Board Home Page Watch Videos of Public Comments
[Skip] Home Find a Park Arizona Map Fee Schedule
PDF Documents Require Adobe Reader
Read External Link Disclaimer